Friday, February 24, 2006

Old wine in a new bottle

What is it with remixes and remakes these days? So long as people don't completely ruin the original song, I have no issues with remixes. Although there are times when I have the urge to puke when I watch remixes like 'Pardesiya'. (Seriously, what IS the problem with that female? With a name like Rakhi too!) It's sad that a whole generation knows about the old classics only because they watch the (questionable) hotties gyrate to the remixes. Not content with tampering the music, some 'creative' souls have now gone one step ahead. Welcome, Ladies and Gentlemen to the age of remakes!

One must start at the beginning. Sanjay Leela Bhansali is, arguably, the guy who started it all by blowing up 50 crores in the making of a film about a guy who's tragic story was unknown to few people, thanks to Saratda, K L Saigal and the living legend, Dilip Kumar. Also to burn his hands in an equally expensive venture was Akbar Khan who made the magnum opus Tajmahal, even as the retouched version of 'Mughal-e-Azam' put an end to any curiousity about the film. Unfortunately Naushad's remarkable compositions for the film went unnoticed.

Today, every director worth his salt is making a remake. Be it RGV, J P Dutta or Pritish Nandy. Even a young talented director like Farhan Akhtar is making 'Don', THE Amitabh Classic. What convinced Farhan that he could recreate Bachchan's charismatic portrayal of Don? SRK, who's playing Don might be able to do a 'khaike paan banaras waala', but can he actually become a very stylish Don AND not look funny while singing 'Main hoon Don'? I almost had a heart attack when I read that Kareena Kapoor was to do the Helen number. Puhleeze...!! I am OK with Urmilas or Ishas trying their luck with 'Yeh mera Dil'..but Kareena is a big NO.

Let me move on to some other remakes that are quickly gathering a lot of publicity. Not only is Ram Gopal Verma remaking Sholay (that, to me, is the ultimate blasphemy), he is even remaking James. Whether audience will want to go watch Mohit Ahlwat doing the dishum-dishum and generally sulking at the world, is left to me seen. RGV's Sholay has Amitabh playing Gabbar's role. The lesser said about this remake, the better.

Then there is the J P Dutta's Umrao Jaan that's in process, with Aishwarya Rai playing the title role and I am left wondering if they will come anywhere close to Muzaffar Ali's original. The only reason I will ever watch this film is because Abhishek Bachchan plays a key character.

Not far behind is Pritish Nandy who is making Sahib Biwi Aur Ghulam. No prizes for guessing who'll portray the sadistic husband. The one and only Salmaan Khan. They got atleast that one right! Priyanka Chopra, who plays the alcoholic wife better start liking the poison. I don't know how else she is going to match upto Meena Kumari's histrionics. The joke is on John Abraham who is playing Bhola, the ghulam in love with his malkin. Don't get me wrong, I quite like John (more on this later). But why pick a stud with six packs and biceps to play the innocent servant, a role made so memorable by none other than Guru Dutt?

A point in favour of Ashutosh Gowarikar who is making Akbar Jodha. Now this is one story I have not heard or seen before. I look forward to a very well researched product, with fine technicians and good music.

Until then, may the Almighty save me and the rest of the movie buffs from the remakes.

8 comments:

Smita said...

There are some remixes that aren't too bad though...Remember the "Saame yeh koun aaya..." which had the 70's look .....There are others which exposed me to songs which I had never heard before and would never have heard for the rest of my life......The unforgettable "Kaanta laga..." that I never got to perform (I hope you remember the ocassion I had chosen for this;)...Again, I was too young to appreciate the original mvies when they were made and I am actually looking fwd to some of the remakes....I find it painful to sit through the old ones and it would be great to have some color ones with all the new crowd of actors......And if some of them were to have John Abraham, thats bonus points!!

Ananya said...

Whats new, Dipole? Bollywood has always been famous for getting "inspired" by Hollywood Movies.Infact most blockbusters we have had in India, have atleast one connection with the English 70mm...take Chachi 420 (Mrs Doubtfire), Black(The Miracle Worker) and Zinda(Korean,Oldboy). With the "going back to roots" buzz in India these days, im glad the new breed of filmmakers are looking within ourselves for inspiration.

Anonymous said...

a rediff reviewer had this to say about Big B playing Gabbar in Sholay.

"imagine Sean Connary playing the villian in the next bond movie".

i thought it was a very smart remark.

Anonymous said...

a rediff reviewer had this to say about Big B playing Gabbar in Sholay.

"imagine Sean Connary playing the villian in the next bond movie".

i thought it was a very smart remark.

-Arvind

Anonymous said...

i apolagise for the double posting. err... i guess this makes it triple posting. :)

Anonymous said...

i am back for the 4th comment.

isn't the links section cloning itself a bit too much for anyone's liking? multiplying like rabbits, what?

smiles.

Arvind

Venkat said...

Plagiarism, thy name is bollywood..earlier it was external.., not it's internal and external.
no suprise though..

Deepali Kulkarni said...

I don't deny that, Venkat. That's the hindi film industry. Although I am and will always be a sucker for hindi films!!
- D